Jonathan Bailey is the first openly gay ‘Sexiest Man Alive’

The tight pants wearing “Wicked” star earned the honour this year. But what other sexy queers should get the nod one day?

Get ready to shout “FIYERO!” from the rooftops: Jonathan Bailey is People’s “Sexiest Man Alive” for 2025. 

The former Bridgerton star is the first openly queer man to be named “Sexiest Man Alive.” And there’s no doubt he deserves it. But it’s also wild that he’s the first gay man to get the nod in the 40 years People has been dolling it out. 

While the actual mechanics of who is named sexiest and why are not necessarily objective, it’s still a fun thought experiment to ponder what other gays have missed out over the yers. No love for Andrew Scott? Ricky Martin? You’re telling me that in 2024 John Krasinski was sexier than Colman Domingo?

We break down what you need to know, along with some other contenders for the crown to keep things queer in 2026.

Senior editor Mel Woods is an English-speaking Vancouver-based writer, editor and audio producer and a former associate editor with HuffPost Canada. A proud prairie queer and ranch dressing expert, their work has also appeared in Vice, Slate, the Tyee, the CBC, the Globe and Mail and the Walrus.

Read More About:
Video, Culture, TV & Film, Video, Celebrity, Media

Keep Reading

A side by side of two black and white photos by photographer Peter Hujar, one a self portrait and the other his piece Orgasmic Man.

The haunting photographs of Peter Hujar

Photographer Peter Hujar’s work revelled in eroticism, pain and the thin line between life and death
Demonstrators put up an LGBT Pride flag at Stonewall National Monument after it was removed by the Trump Administration

Pride flag returns to Stonewall after sudden removal

The Pride flag at Stonewall National Monument was taken down after a crackdown on “improper partisan ideology” in federal landmarks

How a Canadian social media age ban would impact trans people of all ages

Whether it’s requiring government ID or scanning users’ faces, digital age-verification tools pose a host of problems for queer and trans people
A screenshot of sexual health Instagram account Bellesa, which was banned by Meta.

Popular women’s sexual health Instagram hit with sudden Meta ban

The ban on Bellesa Boutique's page, which caters to women and queer people, comes amidst a bigger crackdown on sex content
Advertisement