Diagnosing Difference

Timely film challenges gender identity disorder


The timely documentary Diagnosing Difference examines the medical community’s ongoing practice of treating people whose gender expression is different from their birth-assigned gender as mental patients suffering from a disorder.

Since 1980, the American Psychological Association (APA) has included “gender identity disorder (GID)” in its Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) — what some call the Bible of psychological treatment.

The DSM shapes how doctors treat those who identify on the trans spectrum (not all people who are gender variant identify as trans), and how gender is treated under the law and in social life.

With the APA set to introduce an update to the DSM in 2012 (only the second revision since 1980), pressure is mounting for the section on GID to be removed or heavily revised.

Some of the talking heads in Diagnosing Difference note that GID diagnosis is for now an unfortunate but necessary tool for them to access medical treatment and eventual legal recognition of their chosen gender. Others say the diagnosis — implying sickness — is stigmatizing — socially, culturally and legally.

One of the key threads of the hour-long doc is that there is no monolithic trans experience or community with clearly defined goals and needs. Each trans person needs to be treated as an individual with unique experiences and desires for their gender expression.

It’s a stunningly obvious conclusion that nonetheless bears repeating for how often it is lost on people obsessed with genital status and normative gender expression.

At one point, a trans person recalls how her doctors asked if she enjoyed playing with dolls and makeup as a child, rather than asking if she liked Joan Jett and long guitar solos. It’s a clear reminder that gender is performed and enjoyed in ways as numerous and different as the sum total of humanity, and that we can’t reduce people’s gender expressions to simple categories.

Rob Salerno is a playwright and journalist whose writing has appeared in such publications as Vice, Advocate, NOW and OutTraveler.

Keep Reading

Bliss with an up arrow behind her; Pheromone Killz with a down arrow behind her

‘Canada’s Drag Race’ Season 7, Episode 1 power ranking: Let’s go ride

No elimination means we’re power-ranking the full cast of 12 going into Episode 2
Sasha Colby, Sarain Fox, Brook Lynn Hytes, Hollywood Jade

‘Canada’s Drag Race’ Season 7 premiere recap: Pure Bliss

One queen comes out on top in the Canadian main series’ seventh premiere
Andrew Scott as Ian Charleson looking up

Andrew Scott’s ‘Elsinore’ honours a lost generation. He says we’ve come a long way

The Irish actor’s new Ian Charleson biopic is one of the fall’s biggest films. Scott tells Xtra the movie is more important than its awards buzz
A green background with large letters that say "Free Love" and cherries. In the foreground, a person in white clothes with shoulder-length pink hair and bangs (this is author Michelle Tea).

Michelle Tea will not be toning it down

The “Free Love” author on opening up her marriage, there being no such thing as being grown up and why you should never cast a love spell
Advertisement