Pick of the week: For the Bible Tells Me So

Feeding on the fear of the God-fearing


It’s a sad truth that fear and anger are common emotions that often erupt when conservative religion and visible homosexuality are in the same room.

Just how much anger is made plain in a small and depressing library of excellent documentaries — including Trembling Before G-d, Jesus Camp, Blood in the Face, and Homophobia: That Painful Problem.

Daniel Karslake’s documentary, For the Bible Tells Me So, is a welcome addition to that library not only because it is well crafted and insightful, but because it tempers despair with a healthy dose of optimism.

Karslake approaches his complex subject from numerous angles, all thought provoking.

The director surveys Bible literalists and American evangelists (for whom, apparently, “demon lifestyle” and “abomination” are part of daily speech), and talks with biblical scholars who outright refute (or at least reinterpret) biblical passages commonly thought to explicitly condemn homosexuals to hellfire.

While this discussion is intellectually stimulating, the heartfelt core of the doc is Karslake’s interviews with a diverse handful of American families who are Christian hardliners “absolutely steeped in Scripture.”

Deeply committed to upholding the demon lifestyle/abomination orthodoxy, each family was faced with a crisis of faith when one of its children came out.

Karslake interviews the parents and their children separately, but reveals that even though each person faced a profoundly difficult situation, in the majority of cases unconditional love trumped biblical commandments.

The sole exception is shocking, and perfectly illustrates the chilling words of one Bible scholar: “Fear does terrible things to a society.”

Faced with the venom that comes from the mouths of some outspoken religious conservatives, it’s reasonable to turn, run and hide.

Karslake offers another option. His documentary points out that these so-called leaders grow fat (and rich) from feeding on people’s fear. If these same people see, know, and talk to actual homosexuals their hatred and fear can dissolve.

So long as they’re only aware of the demonic abominations envisioned by their homophobic leaders, however, their dislike will remain intact — and a serious danger.

Keep Reading

Jimmy Heagarty

‘Big Brother 27’ star Jimmy Heagerty is making for great TV. It could be even better with more queer people

By very virtue of their sexuality, queer houseguests cannot have the same experience as their straight competitors

‘RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars 10’ delivers a wildly entertaining finale—after a waste-of-time semifinals

It’s hard to figure out just what producers were thinking with this merge format
Andrea Gibson, left, and Megan Falley, the subjects of the film "Come See Me in the Good Light," pose for a portrait during the Sundance Film Festival on Saturday, Jan. 25, 2025, in Park City, Utah.

Andrea Gibson helped me see life in the good light

Gibson’s poetry about queerness and mortality taught thousands of people how to reject apathy and embrace life
Collage of greyscale photos of a sofa, chair, shelf and the lower bodies of two people, against a purple and pink background

We need queer gathering spaces more than ever

The 11-part series “Taking Space” explores where we go next as the lights of gay bars dim