Pride Toronto members vote to keep police out of the Pride parade

At the AGM, all of Black Lives Matter’s demands for Pride were approved

Pride Toronto’s members have voted overwhelmingly in favour of keeping police out of this year’s and future parades, and to endorse all of Black Lives Matter Toronto’s demands.

The agenda for Pride’s annual general meeting (AGM) was initially set to focus on recapping last year’s highlights in its annual report and on a Q&A with prospective new board members. But members preferred to focus on Black Lives Matter and community concerns about accessibility, corporate sponsorship and anti-black racism.

Here’s Xtra’s recap of the AGM, which took place on Jan 17, 2017.

Pride members vote during the Jan 17 AGM. Credit: Nick Lachance/Daily Xtra

How did Pride Toronto agree to all of BLMTO’s demands?

Members Gwen Bartleman and Kami Chisholm asked Pride Toronto to officially endorse all of Black Lives Matter’s demands, “and commit to [it] in terms of practice, policy and funding priorities.”

But the meeting’s chair said the agenda could not be amended. Any additions must have been added 60 days prior to the meeting, said the chair, an outside facilitator brought in by Pride to run the AGM.

But several community members said they didn’t receive notice 60 days prior to the meeting.

After Bartleman successfully challenged the chair’s ruling, a large majority of attendees voted to add Black Lives Matter to the agenda.

Gary Kinsman, a long-time activist and a founding member of the Toronto Lesbian and Gay Pride Day Committee, said he was “strongly in favour of Black Lives Matter Toronto’s demands.”

“Strongly in favour of Black Lives Matter Toronto’s demands,” says long-time activist Gary Kinsman at the Pride Toronto AGM. Credit: Nick Lachance/Daily XtraPride should not allow police in the parade due to their history of violence against various communities including black and indigenous communities, two-spirit people and trans folks, he said.Police are still targeting men who have sex with men, he pointed out, citing the recent undercover sting at Marie Curtis Park.Pride’s co-chair Alica Hall maintained that Pride Toronto was sticking to its promise to Black Lives Matter. “We made a commitment to Black Lives Matter’s demands. We have not made any new contradictions,” Hall said. “Our goal is to elect five new members who will continue this work and our commitment.”After a heated debate, community members voted overwhelmingly to approve all of Black Lives Matter’s demands, including the one to remove all police floats or booths in all Pride marches, parades and community spaces.

Black Lives Matter Toronto’s nine demands, originally posted on the BLMTO Facebook page. Credit: Black Lives Matter Toronto/FacebookDuring the Pride parade on July 3, 2016, BLMTO staged a 30-minute sit-in and asked that Pride Toronto sign a list of nine demands, the majority of which were to reinstate and fund programming as well as more hiring of queer and trans people of colour, and one asking for the removal of police from the parade. Hall and former executive director Mathieu Chantelois signed the list of demands, but the following day, Chantelois drew heavy criticism for saying that he only signed the demands to “make the parade move.” Chantelois later resigned on Aug 10.Three days after the parade, Jacqie Lucas, a volunteer team lead, resigned in protest over the way Pride handled the Black Lives Matter demands. In September, Pride Toronto’s communications manager Victoria Schwarzl left the organization for a job at another company.Removal of police from floats and booths has become a divisive issue within the LGBT community. It was heatedly discussed at Pride Toronto’s first town hall on Aug 30, when they announced that instead of removing police from Pride, they would leave the decision to a dispute resolution process. In September, they released a lengthy statement apologizing for wrongdoings, a history of anti-black racism and a lack of accessibility at the parade.

Pride Toronto had its first town hall on Aug 30, 2016 to discuss issues arising from last year’s Pride.


What is Pride doing about accessibility and ASL interpreters?

Board members were grilled on the lack of accessibility at Pride, in particular when it comes to ASL. Several community members said that the board needs to have a relationship with the deaf community, and to hire more interpreters from diverse backgrounds.

Pride co-chair Aaron GlynWilliams said that finding interpreters for events is an operational decision made by Pride Toronto staff, not the board. “There’s a strong desire for Pride Toronto to be as diverse as possible in our hiring,” he said, adding that interpreters are chosen depending on who is available at the time.

How are Pride Toronto’s finances?

Last year, Pride Toronto had 33 sponsors, all of which are returning for Pride 2017. These sponsors include major cultural attractions such as the Art Gallery of Ontario, the Royal Ontario Museum and Ripley’s Aquarium. Pride made $2,269,180 in sponsorships, an increase from 2015. Pride’s total revenue for last year totalled $4,409,478, compared to $3,104,906 in 2015.

GlynWilliams said Pride 2016 brought in $600 million in economic spending to Toronto.

However, community members expressed concerns over corporate sponsorship and their attempts to pinkwash for profit.

“The banks are not our friends,” said speaker Kami Chisholm, telling the audience that some trans customers have had issues with TD Canada Trust, one of Pride’s long-time sponsors.

Kami Chisholm told the AGM that the true spirit of Pride has been diluted by corporate sponsorship. Credit: Nick Lachance/Daily XtraChisholm added that Pride should be more focused on returning to a more political, community-focused parade. “It flies in the face of everything we stand for in our communities,” Chisholm said. “It is not our job to fund the city’s economic development.”

Who’s leaving the board?

Treasurer Chris Tremeer, co-chair Aaron GlynWilliams and Dana Suvagau are stepping down as board members.

Co-chair Aaron GlynWilliams (right) is stepping down from the board of directors. Fellow co-chair Alica Hall (left) will remain on the board. Credit: Nick Lachance/Daily XtraWho’s joining the board?This year there were 13 candidates for the five available spots on Pride Toronto’s board. Ten were selected by the board recruitment committee — Paul Bozzo, Sarah Cooper, Nicole Desnoyers, Susan Gapka, Hussain Haider Ali, Robert Hampsey, Elijah Monroe, Kevin Rambally, Maurice Tomlinson and Kenneth Tong.Three members — Rolyn Chambers, Joey Fascio and Akio Maroon — were not selected by the recruitment committee but secured 10 signatures to be eligible for election to the board.Pride Toronto members voted to elect Akio Maroon, Sarah Cooper, Kevin Rambally, Nicole Desnoyers and Elijah Monroe as new members to the board.When is Pride 2017?This year, Pride will take place from June 1–24, 2017.

Eternity Martis is an award-winning journalist and editor who has worked at CBC, CTV and Xtra Magazine. She is the author of the bestselling 2020 memoir They Said This Would Be Fun: Race, Campus Life, and Growing Up, the course developer/instructor of "Reporting on Race: Black Communities in the Media" at Ryerson University and UBC's 2021 Journalist-in-Residence.

Keep Reading

Job discrimination against trans and non-binary people is alive and well

OPINION: A study reveals that we have a long way to go to reach workplace equality for trans and non-binary people

The new generation of gay Conservative sellouts

OPINION: Melissa Lantsman’s and Eric Duncan’s refusals to call out their party’s transphobia is a betrayal of the LGBTQ2S+ community

Over 300 anti-LGBTQ2S+ bills have been introduced this year. This doesn’t mean we should panic

OPINION: While it’s important to watch out for threats, not all threats are created equally. Some of these bills will die a natural death

Xtra’s top LGBTQ2S+ stories of the year

The best and brightest—even most bewildering—stories from a back catalogue brimming with insight