Hiding in plain sight

“Of course I knew the Nazis condemned homosexuality — just look at the Rohm affair — and in light of that I kept a low profile. I didn’t know of anyone in my circle of friends who was persecuted because of their homosexuality. It was hardly ever spoken about. We protected ourselves instinctively. We isolated ourselves and conducted ourselves accordingly; we were cautious.”
— Elisabeth Zimmerman

Elisabeth Zimmerman is one of 10 women interviewed by Claudia Schoppmann for her book on queer women and the Holocaust, Days Of Masquerade. At a recent appearance in Toronto for Holocaust Education Week, the Berlin-based historian talked about the difficulties of such research.

“Even 60 years after the end of the war our knowledge of the lives of lesbian women [during] the Third Reich is sketchy,” Schoppmann told an audience at the Metropolitan Community Church Of Toronto on Nov 5. “For decades, the public took no interest in the subject, partly because lesbians were not among the declared enemies of the Nazi regime and partly because after 1945 there was no… change in attitudes toward homosexuality in either East or West Germany.

“Discrimination simply continued. In this atmosphere of silence the women who had lived through the Nazi period were not encouraged to talk about their experiences. Furthermore, hardly any relevant files or documents have survived.”

First published in German in 1993 and in English three years later, Days Of Masquerade is billed as “the first in-depth account of lesbians living in Germany during the Third Reich.” Schoppmann began the research that became the basis of the book while working on her thesis about Anna Elisabet Weirauch’s Der Skorpion (The Scorpion), a three-volume lesbian novel set in Weimer Republic-era Berlin.

As she details in Days Of Masquerade, women started to join queer-focussed groups such as the Scientific Humanitarian Committee following World War I. Founded by Magnus Hirschfeld in 1897, the main objectives of the group were to repeal Paragraph 175 of the German Criminal Code, which made male homosexuality illegal, and to educate the public about homosexuality.

During this time, several lesbian magazines — including Frauenliebe (Women’s Love), Die Freundin (The Girlfriend) and Garconne — were published. Schoppmann’s research indicates that their combined circulation was in the millions. She also points out that during this time there “were many clubs and bars specifically for or at least tolerant of a lesbian clientele.”

All that quickly changed when the Nazis came to power in 1933 and the fledgling homosexual organizations were dissolved.

“[Queer] bars and clubs were closed or kept under surveillance,” writes Schoppmann. “Books and magazines with homosexual content were collected and destroyed.”

But although gay men were actively rounded up and sent to concentration camps along with other declared enemies of the Nazi regime, lesbians were largely considered beneath notice.

“Gender-specific treatment with respect to homosexuality was based on the different assessment of male and female sexuality in general and can be traced back to the unequal status of men and women,” writes Schoppmann. “The Nazi state assumed that women were ‘naturally’ dependent on men, especially in terms of sexuality, and efforts were made to reinforce this as far as possible.

“Based on a centuries-old patriarchal tradition that declared passivity a female trait, a self-assured sense of female sexuality, including homosexuality, was unfathomable. All of this led a majority of Nazis to believe that female sexuality did not represent a threat to the ‘German national community.'”

Schoppmann says very little new information has become available since Days Of Masquerade was published. Although an exhibit on the subject was prepared in Hamburg, she says she’s unaware of the findings because there wasn’t funding to actually mount the exhibit.

The women Schoppmann interviewed described what it was like to live in Germany during this time. Anneliese W, aka Johnny, recounts the story of a “girlfriend couple” who were fired from their factory jobs Although Johnny kept her hair short, she tells how some of her friends changed their appearance to pass as straight — or got married — in order to be less vulnerable.

Another woman interviewed, Elisabeth Leithauser, was a member of the Communist Youth Association. When she and her girlfriend moved into an apartment in 1938 the Gestapo ransacked it.

“The Gestapo was always around for the whole 12 years,” Leithauser told Schoppmann, “and even if they did leave us alone, relatively speaking, they could have come back at any moment.”

Artist Gertrude Sandmann knew that the Gestapo was coming for her, as a Jewish woman. She left a fake suicide note for those who arrived at her apartment in November 1942 and with the help of her partner of 15 years, Hedwig “Johnny” Koslowski, survived underground until Berlin was liberated.