Gay man opens up about homophobia in St Kitts

Dermot Sargeant says attacks reported to police are rarely, if ever, investigated

Dermot Sargeant is in many ways like his friend Rolston Ryan.

Back in St Kitts and Nevis, where gay sex is punishable by up to 10 years in prison, Ryan was subject to constant harassment. Walking home from work, men would use homophobic slurs calling him “anti man” and “batty man.” Currently, Ryan is facing deportation from Canada, and will be sent back to a place where he has been viciously attacked.

Like Ryan, Sargeant is a gay man from St Kitts and Nevis who came to Canada seeking asylum.

But the difference between Sargeant and Ryan is that while the Canadian government plans to deport Ryan, Sargeant has been allowed to live in Canada as a refugee.

Sargeant, who spoke to Daily Xtra on the phone, had his refugee application approved in 2012 and provided an affidavit in favour of Ryan’s application this year.

Much of the abuse Sargeant suffered in his home country echoes what Ryan described.

He recalls attending a street party where he was heckled for being gay.

“When I was on my way home, I had to go through a park, and two of the guys I got in a fight with, they attacked me and stabbed me in the back over my right shoulder,” he says.

Sargeant says that when he went to parties, he would worry about them playing Jamaican dancehall music. Many dancehall tracks contain extreme homophobic language, and some even call for gay men to be burned alive.

“People [were] coming for me with the lighter, light the lighter literally in my face and I had to leave the party,” he says.

One time, a group of men started harassing him while he was working at a casino. They used homophobic slurs all night while he was dealing blackjack. He eventually had enough and mouthed them off. A few nights later, he was attacked on his way to work and beaten with a two-by-four board.

Like Ryan, Sargeant reported some of this violence to the police. After he was stabbed, Sargeant says he filed a report. But the police did nothing.

In fact, Sargeant says that he was called “anti man” and “batty man” by police officers, who laughed at him. And the police didn’t follow up on his case, despite numerous attempts by Sargeant to get them to act.

“I keep going back because I have to pass the police station in my town to take the bus to go to my work,” he says.


Despite the fact that Sargeant was living in a small town, he says that the police didn’t even attempt to investigate the crime.

“In a village of 5,000 people, how hard is it to go to whoever, to go and question them?” he says. “It was no protection, because the police are not interested in those kinds of cases.”

Ryan’s refugee application was rejected because the government said that the police in St Kitts and Nevis adequately protect their gay citizens.

Sargeant, who became friends with Ryan when they were both in Canada, says that he knew who Ryan was when he lived in St Kitts, though they never spoke.

When asked if he knew Ryan was gay, despite the fact that he wasn’t out at the time, Sargeant was emphatic.

“Oh god, oh god, of course I know he was gay,” he says. “It’s small, you know everybody.”

And according to Sargeant, it’s the smallness of St Kitts that can make it especially dangerous for LGBT people. He once had a boyfriend from Jamaica who said that while Jamaica is more homophobic, it’s harder to live as a gay man in St Kitts.

“[What] he saying is that he don’t get heckled when he passing on the street because nobody knows he’s gay,” Sargeant says. “Jamaica is so big, nobody know you in that sense. But he says that St Kitts is so small.”

Sargeant worries about Ryan’s safety if he’s deported back to St Kitts. Not only will people know that he’s gay, but Sargeant says that gun violence has become such an issue that he fears Ryan could be killed.

“If he go back there, nobody do anything with knife or bottle or fight fist-to-fist now. It’s all about guns,” he says. “I don’t want him to go back. He’s a good guy.”

Read More About:
Power, News, Immigration & Refugees

Keep Reading

Job discrimination against trans and non-binary people is alive and well

OPINION: A study reveals that we have a long way to go to reach workplace equality for trans and non-binary people

The new generation of gay Conservative sellouts

OPINION: Melissa Lantsman’s and Eric Duncan’s refusals to call out their party’s transphobia is a betrayal of the LGBTQ2S+ community

Over 300 anti-LGBTQ2S+ bills have been introduced this year. This doesn’t mean we should panic

OPINION: While it’s important to watch out for threats, not all threats are created equally. Some of these bills will die a natural death

Xtra’s top LGBTQ2S+ stories of the year

The best and brightest—even most bewildering—stories from a back catalogue brimming with insight