Concerns raised with Pride Toronto’s new drink-and-carry program

Some critics say the ID and bag checks target queer and trans people of colour

You’ll be able to walk along Church Street with your drinks at Pride this year, but not without agreeing to some terms and conditions.

Pride Toronto’s new drink-and-carry program will allow people who have purchased a wristband to go anywhere within a designated area with an alcoholic beverage purchased from a participating establishment. This will make Pride Toronto the first street festival in the city where drinking won’t be restricted to patios or beer gardens. However, some critics say that the terms and conditions amount to stop and frisk.

The wristbands, which are available for one day or the full weekend, will allow people to take their drinks along Church Street, starting from Charles Street East down to Dundas Street East.

By purchasing a wristband for the program, a person must agree to a bag and ID check at any time.

Following the announcement of drink-and-carry, comments poured in across social media and Pride Toronto’s Facebook page, criticizing the checks.

Arün Smith, who describes himself as a racialized queer activist, shared his concerns about the terms and conditions on Twitter.

“Under no circumstances is it acceptable to arbitrarily stop and search queer and trans folks at Pride events and/or in community spaces,” Smith wrote.

A tweet from activist Arün Smith about Pride’s drink-and-carry program. Credit: @arun_smith/Twitter

Smith also says there’s an issue around requiring identification.

“When we get further into the areas of identification, we’re now getting into the areas of dead names for trans [people], we’re now getting into bodily interrogation, we’re now getting into the prospect that trans people will be required to declare not simply the presentation of their gender but also the nature of their body, which should be deeply concerning,” he tells Xtra.

In an emailed statement to Xtra, Olivia Nuamah, Pride Toronto’s executive director, says that the ID and bag check policy only applies to those who have purchased a wristband.

“Only if you choose to participate in the program will your ID be checked, as it would be if you were purchasing alcohol from any vendor,” Nuamah says in the statement. She adds that bags will be searched by security for illegal substances, and that they would have guidance from volunteers trained in harm reduction.


Corinne Alstrom-Sonne, a community member, tells Xtra she worries how bans on certain objects such as large bags, as well as medications in non-approved containers, will impact those who have disabilities.

Pride Toronto has faced scrutiny that the festival has moved away from its roots as a protest and space for marginalized people and prioritizes corporate sponsorship over the LGBT community’s needs.

Alstrom-Sonne says that she saw the event and conditions surrounding it as the last straw, deciding to organize a “funeral” for Toronto Pride.

“Why is it that it’s basically become St Patricks day but with rainbows instead of shamrocks? Why is it that it’s just this big party, and I am feeling less and less included,” Alstrom-Sonne says.

Nuamah’s statement acknowledges the changing Village, but says that the steps Pride is taking are necessary to support its growth.

“As you walk along our regular festival footprint, you will notice that our traditional spaces have changed and have been replaced with condos,” Nuamah says. “In order for us to support the growth of the festival and its needs, we are piloting this premiere program.”

Sophie is a reporter and incoming law student at the University of Calgary. She has previously written for Beach Metro News and the Ubyssey, and has lived in Toronto and Vancouver.

Keep Reading

Job discrimination against trans and non-binary people is alive and well

OPINION: A study reveals that we have a long way to go to reach workplace equality for trans and non-binary people

The new generation of gay Conservative sellouts

OPINION: Melissa Lantsman’s and Eric Duncan’s refusals to call out their party’s transphobia is a betrayal of the LGBTQ2S+ community

Over 300 anti-LGBTQ2S+ bills have been introduced this year. This doesn’t mean we should panic

OPINION: While it’s important to watch out for threats, not all threats are created equally. Some of these bills will die a natural death

Xtra’s top LGBTQ2S+ stories of the year

The best and brightest—even most bewildering—stories from a back catalogue brimming with insight