European court: Faith can’t trump gay couples’ rights

BY NATASHA BARSOTTI — The European Parliament’s Intergroup on LGBT rights reports that the European Court of Human Rights has made a “landmark ruling” that religious beliefs cannot trump the rights of gay couples.

The ruling upheld British laws that prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation, the rights group says, noting that among the cases the court looked at were two brought by Christians who contended their beliefs permitted them to deny service to gay couples.

In one case, the court considered the dismissal of London civil registrar Lillian Ladele for refusing to officiate at civil partnership ceremonies for gay couples after they became legal in 2005. Ladele says she was discriminated against because of her faith, but the court found there was no discrimination, ruling that British courts’ decision to uphold her dismissal “struck the right balance between her right to freedom of religion, and same-sex couples’ right not to be discriminated against,” the Intergroup reports.

In another case, a counsellor who was dismissed for his refusal to work with gay couples also cited incompatibility with his religious beliefs. The European court ruled there was no violation of his right to freedom of belief.

Sophie in ‘t Veld, a member of the European Parliament (MEP) and vice-president of the LGBT Intergroup, is quoted as saying that the court “conclusively” demonstrated that “the principle of equality and equal treatment cannot be circumvented with a simple reference to religion.”

“British law rightly protects LGBT people from discrimination, and there is no exemption for religious believers. Religion and belief are deeply private and personal, and should never be used to diminish the rights of others,” adds Michael Cashman, also an MEP and the LGBT Group’s co-president.

An appeal of the court’s ruling may be filed within three months.

Landing image: Wikipedia (CherryX)

Natasha Barsotti is originally from Trinidad and Tobago in the Caribbean. She had high aspirations of representing her country in Olympic Games sprint events, but after a while the firing of the starting gun proved too much for her nerves. So she went off to university instead. Her first professional love has always been journalism. After pursuing a Master of Journalism at UBC , she began freelancing at Xtra West — now Xtra Vancouver — in 2006, becoming a full-time reporter there in 2008.

Keep Reading

Trans issues didn’t doom the Democrats

OPINION: The Republicans won ending on a giant anti-trans note, but Democrats ultimately failed to communicate on class

Xtra Explains: Trans girls and sports

Debunking some of the biggest myths around trans girls and fairness in sports

How ‘mature minor’ laws let trans kids make their own decisions

Canadian law lets some youth make medical or legal decisions for themselves, but how does it work?

To combat transphobia, we need to engage with the people who spread it

OPINION: opening up a dialogue with those we disagree with is key if we want to achieve widespread social change